NSA Arbitration

The No Surprises Act for Providers: Billing Rules and Compliance Basics

What the No Surprises Act means for provider billing: protected services, patient cost sharing, notice and consent, good faith estimates and disputes.

12 min read

The No Surprises Act is a federal law that protects patients from unexpected out-of-network bills in specific situations, sets how their cost sharing is calculated, and gives providers and health plans a process to settle payment disputes. Its main protections took effect on January 1, 2022. For providers, it changes how certain out-of-network claims are billed, what can be collected from patients, what notices must be given, and how payment disagreements are resolved.

This guide covers the core rules from a billing perspective. It is a practical overview, not legal advice. The rules have been revised through federal rulemaking and affected by litigation, so confirm the latest CMS No Surprises Act guidance before making decisions on specific claims.

Who the law affects

The No Surprises Act applies to:

  • Group health plans and health insurance issuers offering group or individual coverage, including self-funded employer plans.
  • Health care providers and facilities, including hospitals, hospital outpatient departments, critical access hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers.
  • Providers of air ambulance services.

Enforcement is shared by HHS, the Department of Labor and the Treasury, with state insurance regulators often involved.

Providers most affected tend to be those who often treat patients without choosing their network status, such as emergency medicine, anesthesiology, radiology, pathology and other hospital-based specialties. Any provider that treats patients out of network in a protected setting needs to understand the rules.

Which services are protected

The federal protections apply in three main situations.

Emergency services

Emergency services must be covered without prior authorization and without regard to whether the provider or facility is in network. Patient cost sharing cannot exceed what it would be in network. The protections extend to certain post-stabilization services unless specific notice and consent conditions are met.

Non-emergency services at in-network facilities

When a patient receives non-emergency care at an in-network hospital, hospital outpatient department, critical access hospital or ambulatory surgical center, out-of-network providers who treat the patient at that facility generally cannot bill the patient more than in-network cost sharing. This addresses situations such as an out-of-network anesthesiologist or assistant surgeon participating in a procedure the patient scheduled with an in-network surgeon.

Air ambulance services

Out-of-network air ambulance services are covered by the federal protections. Ground ambulance services are not, although some states have their own ground ambulance protections, and federal advisory work on ground ambulance billing has been ongoing.

What patients pay for protected services

For protected services, the patient’s cost sharing is based on in-network rules:

  • Copays, coinsurance and deductibles are calculated as if the service were in network.
  • Cost sharing is generally based on a “recognized amount,” which may come from an all-payer model, a state statute or, most often, the qualifying payment amount (QPA), roughly the plan’s median in-network rate for that service in the region.
  • Amounts the patient pays count toward in-network deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums.

The provider cannot balance bill the patient for the difference between its charge and the plan’s payment. Payment disputes are between the provider and the plan.

In limited circumstances, an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility can ask the patient to waive the balance billing protections for non-emergency services by giving a standard written notice and obtaining the patient’s signed consent. The rules are strict:

  • The notice and consent must use the federal standard documents or meet their requirements.
  • Timing rules apply. For services scheduled at least 72 hours in advance, the notice must be given at least 72 hours before the service. For services scheduled within 72 hours, the notice must be given on the day the appointment is made and at least three hours before the service.
  • The notice must include a good faith estimate of charges and a list of in-network providers at the facility who could provide the service.
  • The patient can refuse, and the provider cannot require consent as a condition of care.

Notice and consent cannot be used for ancillary services, which include emergency medicine, anesthesiology, pathology, radiology and neonatology; services by assistant surgeons, hospitalists and intensivists; and diagnostic services, including radiology and laboratory services. It also cannot be used when no in-network provider is available at the facility, or for unforeseen urgent medical needs that arise during the service.

In practice, notice and consent is a narrow exception. Most providers should assume the protections apply to their out-of-network services at in-network facilities.

Good faith estimates for uninsured and self-pay patients

The No Surprises Act also requires providers and facilities to give good faith estimates to patients who are uninsured or who do not plan to use their insurance.

When an estimate is required

  • When the patient schedules an item or service at least three business days in advance.
  • When the patient asks for an estimate.

What the estimate includes

The estimate must list expected charges for the primary item or service and items and services reasonably expected to be provided with it, including those from co-providers and co-facilities, along with codes, diagnosis information where applicable, and required disclaimers. Federal guidance has allowed some flexibility on including co-provider charges while further rules are developed, so check the current enforcement position.

Timing

  • Scheduled at least three business days ahead: the estimate must be provided within one business day of scheduling.
  • Scheduled at least ten business days ahead: within three business days of scheduling.
  • Requested by the patient: within three business days of the request.

Patient-provider dispute resolution

If an uninsured or self-pay patient is billed substantially more than the estimate, currently defined as at least $400 more for any provider or facility, the patient may start a patient-provider dispute resolution process within a set period after receiving the bill. Keep copies of every estimate issued, since they may be needed if a patient disputes a bill.

The rules for estimates to insured patients, sometimes called the advanced explanation of benefits, have been delayed pending further rulemaking.

Payment by the plan

For protected out-of-network services, the plan has 30 calendar days from receipt of a clean claim to pay an initial amount or deny. The plan’s payment is often based on its own methodology and may be related to the QPA.

The plan’s response should include certain information, such as the QPA for each item or service and contact information for starting open negotiation. These disclosures matter when the provider decides whether to dispute the payment.

When the payment seems too low: open negotiation and IDR

If an out-of-network provider disagrees with the plan’s payment for a protected service, the federal process is:

  1. Open negotiation. A 30-business-day negotiation window opens when either side sends the standard notice, which must happen within 30 business days of the payment or denial reaching the provider.
  2. Independent dispute resolution (IDR). If negotiation does not resolve the dispute, either party may initiate federal IDR within four business days after the open negotiation period ends, through the federal IDR portal.
  3. An independent arbiter. A certified entity is chosen, each side files its offer with support, and the entity’s decision binds both parties.

The IDR process has many detailed requirements, including eligibility rules, fees, batching rules and deadlines. We cover it in two dedicated guides: a walkthrough of each federal IDR stage and a guide to offer strategy and common eligibility mistakes.

State laws and the federal framework

Before the No Surprises Act, many states had their own surprise billing laws. These still matter:

  • For state-regulated plans, a specified state law may determine the out-of-network payment amount and dispute process instead of the federal IDR process.
  • Some states allow self-funded plans, which are generally governed by federal law, to opt into the state process.
  • The state process and the federal process have different timelines and forms.

Determining which process applies to a claim is one of the first and most important steps. Plans should state on the initial payment or remittance which process governs, and the federal IDR portal asks parties to confirm eligibility. When in doubt, consult the applicable state regulator’s guidance and CMS resources.

Other provider obligations under the law

The balance billing rules get most of the attention, but the No Surprises Act includes several other requirements that touch providers.

Disclosure of patient protections

Providers and facilities must make publicly available, post prominently and give to patients a one-page notice explaining the federal balance billing protections, any applicable state protections and how to contact the appropriate authorities if a patient believes the protections were violated. In practice, this usually means:

  • A notice on the practice or facility website.
  • A notice posted where patients check in or pay.
  • A copy given to patients, generally no later than when payment is requested.

CMS has published a model disclosure notice. Providers that work within a facility may be able to rely on the facility’s disclosure in some cases if there is a written agreement, but responsibility should be clearly assigned.

Provider directories

The law includes requirements aimed at keeping plan provider directories accurate, including expectations that providers send updated information to plans when key details change and at specified times. It also addresses what happens when a patient relied on an inaccurate directory listing. Keep directory information current with every plan you participate in, and keep records of updates sent.

Continuity of care

When a provider leaves a plan’s network, or a contract ends, the law gives certain patients who are in active treatment, sometimes called continuing care patients, the right to continue receiving care from that provider for a transitional period at in-network cost sharing. The plan is responsible for notifying affected patients. Providers should be prepared for these situations when contracts end, including how to bill during the transition and what terms apply.

Complaints and enforcement

Patients can submit complaints about possible violations to the federal No Surprises Help Desk, and state regulators may also take complaints. Enforcement responsibility is shared between federal and state authorities depending on the state and the type of entity. Civil monetary penalties can apply to violations. A provider that receives an inquiry should respond promptly and with documentation, which is another reason to keep complete records of notices, estimates and patient bills.

Billing workflow changes for providers

The No Surprises Act affects several steps of the revenue cycle.

Registration and verification

Identify whether the patient is insured, uninsured or self-pay, and whether the provider is in network with the patient’s plan. For facility-based providers, find out whether the facility is in network, since that affects whether protections apply. Our benefits verification team can help build this into the front end.

Scheduling

For uninsured and self-pay patients, trigger the good faith estimate process at scheduling. For out-of-network providers who may use notice and consent in permitted situations, build the timing requirements into the scheduling workflow.

Claim submission

Submit claims accurately and promptly. Some payers expect specific indicators on claims for services subject to the No Surprises Act. Track the date the claim was received so you can tell when the initial payment is due.

Payment posting

When posting payments for out-of-network claims, flag those that may be subject to the No Surprises Act and record the payment date, the amount, the QPA disclosed and any remark codes. This date starts the open negotiation clock.

Patient billing

For protected services, bill the patient only the in-network cost-sharing amount the plan indicates. Do not send balance bills for the difference.

Dispute tracking

Keep a tracker of NSA-eligible claims with key dates: claim submission, initial payment, open negotiation start and end, IDR initiation deadline, entity selection, offer submission and determination. Missing these deadlines can forfeit the right to dispute.

Common compliance risks

  • Balance billing protected patients. Sending a bill for more than in-network cost sharing for a protected service can lead to complaints and enforcement.
  • Improper use of notice and consent. Using consent forms for ancillary services or without meeting timing rules does not waive the protections.
  • Missing good faith estimates. Failing to provide estimates to uninsured and self-pay patients, or providing incomplete estimates.
  • Missed dispute deadlines. Starting negotiation or IDR late means losing the chance to challenge the payment through the federal process.
  • Poor records. Without records of claims, payments, notices and estimates, a provider cannot support its position in a dispute or audit.

Specialty notes

  • Emergency medicine: nearly all out-of-network emergency claims are protected. Strong tracking of payments and dispute deadlines matters most here. See emergency medicine.
  • Anesthesiology: the waiver route is closed for anesthesia, which the rules classify as ancillary. Out-of-network anesthesia at in-network facilities is generally protected. See anesthesiology.
  • Orthopedics and surgical specialties: assistant surgeons and other out-of-network participants in scheduled procedures at in-network facilities may be subject to the protections. See orthopedics.

Practical scenarios

The rules are easier to apply with examples. The scenarios below are simplified illustrations, not legal determinations.

An out-of-network emergency physician treats an insured patient in a hospital emergency department. The visit is an emergency service and is protected. The patient owes in-network cost sharing as indicated by the plan. The physician’s group bills the plan, receives an initial payment or denial, and may start open negotiation if it disagrees with the amount.

An out-of-network anesthesiologist provides anesthesia for a scheduled procedure at an in-network ambulatory surgical center. The service is a non-emergency service at an in-network facility, and anesthesia is an ancillary service, so notice and consent cannot be used. The patient is protected and owes only in-network cost sharing.

An uninsured patient schedules an office procedure two weeks in advance. The practice must provide a good faith estimate within three business days of scheduling. If the final bill is substantially higher than the estimate, the patient may be able to use patient-provider dispute resolution.

A patient is injured in a car accident and treated in an emergency department. The emergency service protections apply to the patient’s health plan coverage, but auto insurance may also be involved depending on state law and the policy. Coordination of benefits needs to be sorted out early. See our guide to PIP, no-fault and workers’ compensation billing.

An NSA readiness checklist

  1. Staff know which services and settings are protected.
  2. Network status of the provider and the facility is checked for each patient.
  3. Patients receiving protected services are billed only in-network cost sharing.
  4. Notice and consent, if used, is limited to permitted services and meets timing and content rules.
  5. Good faith estimates are issued to uninsured and self-pay patients on time, and copies are kept.
  6. Out-of-network payments are flagged and dated at posting.
  7. A tracker records open negotiation and IDR deadlines for each disputed claim.
  8. Staff check whether a state law or federal process applies before starting a dispute.
  9. The team reviews CMS guidance for changes at regular intervals.

NSA compliance and dispute support

On protected out-of-network claims, Expert MBS supports providers with NSA arbitration, from identifying eligible claims and tracking deadlines to open negotiation and federal IDR submissions, along with medical billing that handles out-of-network claims correctly from the start. We keep regulatory statements general and current and work from your claims data.

If you want a second look at disputed out-of-network payments, talk to Expert MBS.

Questions about The No Surprises Act for Providers: Billing Rules and Compliance Basics

Which services does the No Surprises Act protect?

The federal protections apply to emergency services, including certain post-stabilization services; non-emergency services furnished by out-of-network providers at participating facilities such as hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers; and out-of-network air ambulance services. Ground ambulance services are not covered by these federal protections.

Can an out-of-network provider balance bill a patient under the No Surprises Act?

For protected services, the provider generally cannot bill the patient more than the in-network cost-sharing amount. In limited non-emergency situations, certain providers can obtain the patient's written consent to waive the protections, but this is not allowed for ancillary services and some other situations.

What is a good faith estimate?

A good faith estimate is a written estimate of expected charges that providers and facilities must give uninsured and self-pay patients who schedule care in advance or ask for an estimate. The rules specify timing and content.

How does an out-of-network provider dispute a payment under the No Surprises Act?

The provider can start a 30-business-day open negotiation period with the plan after receiving the initial payment or denial. When talks fail, either side has a four-business-day window after negotiation closes to file for federal IDR, provided the dispute qualifies.

Does state law still apply?

In some cases, yes. For state-regulated plans, a qualifying state statute or all-payer model can set the out-of-network amount in place of the federal process. Self-funded employer plans generally follow the federal rules, though some states let these plans opt into state processes.

Related articles

Talk to us about your practice

A free consultation to review your billing workflow and where support would help.