The Federal No Surprises Act IDR Process, Step by Step
A step-by-step guide to federal NSA IDR: eligibility, open negotiation, initiation, IDR entity selection, offers, fees, decisions and payment.
The federal independent dispute resolution (IDR) process is how out-of-network providers and health plans settle payment disagreements for services protected by the No Surprises Act. It is a structured, deadline-driven process: open negotiation, initiation through a federal portal, selection of a certified IDR entity, submission of offers, and a binding decision that picks one side’s number.
This guide walks through each step in order, with the deadlines and practical tasks at each stage. It reflects the federal framework as published by the Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor and the Treasury. Parts of the IDR rules have been revised through rulemaking and affected by court decisions, so confirm current requirements on the CMS No Surprises Act website before acting on a specific dispute.
For the broader rules on balance billing, notice and consent, and good faith estimates, see our guide to the No Surprises Act for providers.
The process at a glance
| Stage | Key deadline |
|---|---|
| Plan sends initial payment or denial | Within 30 calendar days after receiving a clean claim |
| Start open negotiation | Within 30 business days after receiving the initial payment or denial |
| Open negotiation period | 30 business days from the date the notice is sent |
| Initiate federal IDR | Within 4 business days after open negotiation ends |
| Select certified IDR entity | Parties jointly select within 3 business days of initiation, otherwise the Departments select |
| Submit offers and pay entity fee | Within 10 business days after the entity is selected |
| Determination | Within 30 business days after the entity is selected |
| Payment of any amount owed | Within 30 calendar days after the determination |
Business days and calendar days are different, and the difference matters. Federal holidays do not count as business days. Build both into your tracking.
Step 1: Confirm the claim is a qualified IDR item or service
Before investing time in a dispute, confirm the claim can use the federal process. In general, a claim may be eligible when:
- The service falls under the law’s protections: emergency care, scheduled care by an out-of-network clinician at a participating facility, or out-of-network air ambulance transport.
- The patient’s coverage is subject to the federal payment rules for that service. Where a state surprise-billing law or all-payer arrangement sets the rate, the state route usually governs.
- The patient did not validly waive the protections through notice and consent, where that is permitted.
- The claim has gone through open negotiation without a resolution.
- The claim is not barred by the cooling-off period described below.
Check the plan’s remittance or initial payment notice. Plans are required to disclose information such as the qualifying payment amount (QPA) and whether the claim is subject to the federal process, along with contact information for open negotiation. If that information is missing or unclear, ask the plan for it in writing.
Uninsured and self-pay patients do not use this process. They have a separate patient-provider dispute resolution process tied to good faith estimates.
Step 2: Record the initial payment or denial date
The clock for open negotiation starts when the provider receives the plan’s initial payment or notice of denial. Record:
- The date the remittance or notice was received.
- The amount paid, if any, for each item or service.
- The QPA disclosed for each item or service.
- Claim number, patient, date of service, codes and the plan or issuer name.
- The plan’s funding arrangement, if disclosed.
This record becomes the foundation of your dispute file. Without the receipt date, you cannot calculate any deadline reliably.
Step 3: Start open negotiation
Either party can start open negotiation by sending an open negotiation notice to the other within 30 business days, beginning on the day the provider receives the initial payment or notice of denial. The Departments publish a standard notice that includes the claim details, the amount of the initial payment, an offer of an out-of-network rate and contact information.
Practical points:
- Use the standard notice and include every required element. An incomplete notice can create eligibility problems later.
- Send it to the right contact. Use the contact information the plan provided for open negotiation.
- Keep proof of delivery. Save the date and method of sending and any confirmation.
- Include a reasoned offer. A specific counteroffer gives the plan something to respond to and documents good faith efforts to negotiate.
During the 30 business days
Open negotiation lasts 30 business days from the day the notice is sent. Use it. Follow up with the plan, respond to counteroffers and document every exchange. Many disputes settle in this period, and a documented negotiation history can matter later.
If you reach an agreement, record the agreed amount and confirm when it will be paid. If you do not, prepare for IDR initiation while the period is still running, because the next window is short.
Step 4: Initiate federal IDR
If open negotiation ends without agreement, either party may initiate IDR within four business days, beginning on the business day after the open negotiation period ends. Initiation happens through the federal IDR portal, and the initiating party must also send a notice of IDR initiation to the other party.
The initiation includes information such as:
- The parties and their contact information.
- The items or services in dispute, with dates, codes and claim numbers.
- The place of service and the state.
- The QPA and the date open negotiation began.
- Whether the dispute is a single or batched determination.
- The initiating party’s preferred certified IDR entity.
Four business days is very little time. Have the claim data and documents ready before open negotiation ends.
Extensions for extenuating circumstances
The rules allow certain deadlines to be extended in extenuating circumstances, such as natural disasters, at the Departments’ discretion and on request. Do not plan around an extension. Treat every deadline as fixed.
Step 5: Select a certified IDR entity
Certified IDR entities are organizations certified by the Departments to decide disputes. They publish fee ranges and must not have conflicts of interest with the parties.
The initiating party proposes an entity in its initiation. The non-initiating party can agree or object and propose another. The parties are expected to jointly select an entity within three business days after initiation. If they do not, the Departments select one, generally at random.
The selected entity checks for conflicts of interest and reviews whether the dispute is eligible for the federal process. The non-initiating party can raise eligibility objections, so make sure your eligibility facts are documented.
Step 6: Pay fees
Two kinds of fees apply.
- Administrative fee. Each party pays a non-refundable administrative fee for each dispute to cover the federal government’s costs of running the process. The amount is set by the Departments and has been revised over time, including after litigation.
- Certified IDR entity fee. Each party pays the selected entity’s fee, generally when submitting its offer. After the determination, the entity refunds the fee to the party whose offer was selected. Entities charge within ranges the Departments approve, with separate fees for batched disputes.
Because fee amounts change, check the current amounts on the CMS website when you prepare each dispute. Fees should factor into your decision about which claims to take to IDR, particularly for lower-value services, which is one reason batching matters.
Step 7: Submit your offer and supporting information
Within 10 business days after the certified IDR entity is selected, each party submits:
- An offer. A single payment amount for each item or service in dispute, expressed as a dollar amount.
- Required information. Providers typically submit information such as the size of the practice or facility, the practice specialty or facility type, and the geographic region. Plans submit information such as the coverage area, the QPA and whether the plan is fully insured or self-funded.
- Additional information. Each party may submit additional information relevant to the factors the entity must consider.
The entity can request further information. Respond on time.
Writing a strong offer is a subject of its own. See our companion guide on building a strong IDR offer and avoiding ineligibility.
What the entity considers
The statute directs the certified IDR entity to consider the QPA and certain additional information when submitted, including:
- The provider’s level of training, experience and quality and outcomes measurements.
- The market share of the provider or plan in the geographic region.
- The acuity of the patient and the complexity of the service.
- For facilities, academic affiliation, patient mix and the range of services offered.
- Demonstrations of good faith efforts, or lack of them, to enter into network agreements, and contracted rates between the parties during the previous four plan years.
The entity may also consider other credible information related to the offers, with limits.
What the entity cannot consider
The statute prohibits the entity from considering:
- Usual and customary charges.
- The amount the provider would have billed if the protections did not apply, often called billed charges.
- Payment rates by public payers, such as Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP and TRICARE.
How the weighting has changed
Early federal rules required entities to begin with a presumption that the offer closest to the QPA was the appropriate amount. Federal courts vacated that approach, and later rules giving the QPA special weight were also challenged and partly vacated. Under current guidance, entities consider the QPA and the other statutory factors without a presumption in favor of the QPA. Because litigation over the QPA and related rules has continued, check current guidance for the latest position.
Step 8: The determination
The certified IDR entity must issue a written determination within 30 business days after it is selected. The process is often described as “baseball-style” arbitration: the entity chooses one of the two offers. It cannot split the difference or pick a different number.
The determination is binding on the parties, with limited exceptions such as fraud or misrepresentation, and is not subject to judicial review except in narrow circumstances set out in the statute.
Step 9: Payment
If the selected offer is higher than what the plan already paid, the plan must pay the difference within 30 calendar days after the determination. If the provider has been paid more than the selected amount, the rules address refunds. Track determinations and payment due dates, and follow up if payment does not arrive on time.
Record the result for each claim: the selected offer, the amount paid and the date. Over time, these results inform your decisions about which disputes to pursue.
Step 10: The 90-day cooling-off period
After a determination, the party that initiated the dispute cannot initiate another IDR dispute against that same opponent over the same or similar services for 90 calendar days. Claims for those items or services that arise during the cooling-off period can still be submitted to IDR, but only after the period ends, within 30 business days.
Keep a log of each 90-day pause by plan and service type so held claims are filed on time.
Batching related claims
The rules allow multiple qualified items or services to be considered together in a single dispute when certain conditions are met. Under the rules as originally issued, batched items or services generally had to:
- Be billed by the same provider or group of providers, or the same facility.
- Involve payment by the same plan or issuer.
- Be the same or similar items or services, generally meaning billed under the same service code or a comparable code.
- Have been furnished within the same 30-business-day period, or the cooling-off period, as applicable.
The Departments’ guidance on batching was challenged in court, and parts of it were vacated, after which the Departments issued revised guidance. Proposed rules on IDR operations have also addressed batching. Because these rules have changed, confirm the current batching criteria before you combine claims.
Batching can make the process more efficient and lower the cost per claim, but a batch that does not meet the criteria may be found ineligible.
Facilities and air ambulance providers
The same framework applies to out-of-network facilities, such as hospitals providing emergency services, and to air ambulance providers, with some differences in the information considered. For facilities, the entity may consider teaching status, case mix and scope of services. For air ambulance services, the statute lists additional factors, such as the vehicle type, the population density of the pick-up location and the clinical capability of the vehicle. Facilities and air ambulance providers should check the specific rules that apply to them before preparing offers.
Building a deadline tracker
An IDR program lives or dies on deadlines. A tracker for each claim should include:
- Claim submission date and plan receipt date.
- Date initial payment or denial received.
- Open negotiation deadline (30 business days after receipt).
- Date open negotiation notice sent.
- Open negotiation end date (30 business days after notice).
- IDR initiation deadline (4 business days after negotiation ends).
- Date IDR initiated and dispute reference number.
- Entity selection date.
- Offer and fee deadline (10 business days after selection).
- Determination due date (30 business days after selection).
- Determination result.
- Payment due date (30 calendar days after determination) and payment received.
- Cooling-off period end date, if applicable.
Use a business-day calculator that excludes federal holidays. Review the tracker daily during active disputes.
Common reasons disputes fail on process
- Open negotiation never properly started, or the notice was incomplete.
- IDR initiated outside the four-business-day window.
- The claim was subject to a specified state law rather than the federal process.
- The service was not a qualified IDR item or service.
- Batched claims did not meet the batching criteria.
- Fees or offers were not submitted on time.
- The claim was within a cooling-off period.
Each of these is preventable with a clear workflow. Our companion guide covers eligibility and offer strategy in more depth.
Who should own IDR in your practice
IDR requires billing data, contract knowledge, clinical context and strict deadline management. In many practices, it falls to the billing team, which may not have time for the volume. Specialties with frequent out-of-network facility-based care, such as emergency medicine and anesthesiology, often see enough eligible claims to justify a dedicated process.
A step-by-step IDR checklist
- Confirm the service is protected and the federal process applies.
- Record the date the initial payment or denial was received and the QPA.
- Send a complete open negotiation notice within 30 business days and keep proof.
- Negotiate in good faith and document every exchange.
- Prepare IDR initiation data before the negotiation period ends.
- Initiate IDR within four business days through the federal portal and notify the other party.
- Agree on or accept a certified IDR entity.
- Pay the administrative fee and the entity fee on time.
- Submit a supported offer and required information within 10 business days of entity selection.
- Track the determination and payment due dates.
- Track cooling-off periods and submit held claims within the allowed window.
- Check CMS guidance for changes before each new batch of disputes.
IDR workflow support from Expert MBS
The arbitration team at Expert MBS provides NSA arbitration support for out-of-network providers: identifying eligible claims, tracking business-day deadlines, sending open negotiation notices, preparing IDR initiations and offers, and following determinations through to payment. We also handle the underlying medical billing so out-of-network claims are flagged from the moment the remittance arrives.
To review out-of-network claims or set up an IDR workflow, ask about NSA arbitration support.
Questions about The Federal No Surprises Act IDR Process, Step by Step
What is No Surprises Act IDR?
Independent dispute resolution (IDR) is the federal process created by the No Surprises Act for out-of-network providers, facilities and air ambulance providers to resolve payment disputes with health plans for qualified items and services. A certified IDR entity chooses one of the two parties' payment offers.
How long is open negotiation before IDR?
Open negotiation lasts 30 business days. Either party must start it within 30 business days after the provider receives the plan's initial payment or notice of denial. If the dispute is not resolved, IDR can be initiated within four business days after the negotiation period ends.
Who pays the IDR fees?
Both sides do. Each pays a per-dispute administrative charge that is never returned, and each pays the arbiter's fee up front, with only the winner getting that fee back. Fee amounts are set by the Departments and have changed over time, so check current CMS guidance.
How long does the IDR entity take to decide?
Under the regulations, the entity has 30 business days from its selection to decide. Any amount owed must then be paid within 30 calendar days of the determination.
Can several claims be combined in one IDR dispute?
Yes, in certain circumstances. Batching is allowed for qualified items and services that meet specific criteria, such as the same provider or facility, the same plan and the same or similar services within a defined period. The batching rules have been affected by litigation and rulemaking, so confirm current requirements.
Does IDR apply to every out-of-network claim?
No. It covers only qualified items and services under the federal payment rules, when no state surprise-billing law or all-payer model controls the rate, and when the other eligibility conditions are satisfied.
Related articles
Building a Strong NSA IDR Offer and Avoiding Ineligible Disputes
How out-of-network providers prepare supported NSA IDR offers, understand the QPA, document their case and avoid common ineligibility problems.
The No Surprises Act for Providers: Billing Rules and Compliance Basics
What the No Surprises Act means for provider billing: protected services, patient cost sharing, notice and consent, good faith estimates and disputes.